Elias Boudinot: Hero or Heretic?
Elias Boudinot, the original editor of the Cherokee Phoenix and
Ridge Party member, is the main topic of discussion and
analysis. His rationality that led to the ceding of Cherokee
land in 1835 is superficially arbitrary; did he exercise proper
and rational judgment for the good of the Indians, or rather out
of clumsiness? Boudinot had a heavy influence in the removal
process of the Indians and acted as a mediator between policy
and the dissemination of these policies to the people of Georgia
– Indians and Americans alike – in the years from 1829 to 1832.
This pathfinder seeks to establish the reason for Boudinot’s
volition to cede Cherokee land, and if this reason was without
neglect to possible immediate negative effects for the Indians.
Boudinot’s published stances and his personal letters to
correspondents in regards to the removal process of the Indians
are of particular scrutiny in this study. By clarifying
Boudinot’s ostensible motives through the study of these
articles and epistolary exchanges, this analysis will evaluate
his rationale from which the justice of Boudinot’s assassination
in 1839 will be derived.
Primary Sources
Boudinot, Elias. Cherokee Editor: The
Writings of Elias Boudinot. Ed. Theda Perdue. Knoxville: University of Tennessee
Press, 1983.
This source has impeccable information; this source contains primary editorials,
pamphlets, articles, and letters all in which were written by Boudinot himself. Perdue has
done rigorous scholarly work in gathering the editorials from the Cherokee Phoenix. This
source was referenced in The
Trail of Tears and Indian Removal,
by Amy Sturgis, and was consequentially located at The
University of Texas Library
PCL Stacks in Austin, Texas. This source may also be referred to
through Google Books.
Secondary Sources
Parins, James W. Elias Cornelius Boudinot: A
Life on the Cherokee Border. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2006.
This source contains a short biography of Elias Boudinot with
a focus on the years
when Cherokee removal conflicts and political actions dictated
his life. Parins’s work
focuses on Elias Cornelius Boudinot, the son of Elias Boudinot,
so should not be used
as a foundation for detailed scholarly biography of the Cherokee Phoenix editor. This work was
primarily written for scholars of the son of Elias Boudinot, not
the Cherokee Phoenix editor.
This book was referred to through The University of Texas Library PCL Stacks in Austin,
Texas. It may also be referred to through Google Books.
Wilkins, Thurman. Cherokee
Tragedy: The Story of the Ridge Family and the Decimation of a People. London: The
Macmillan Company, 1970.
This source is written
primarily about John Ridge, who was a member of the Treaty Party
with Boudinot, and Ridge’s
family. Wilkins delves into the relationship between Ridge and Boudinot, providing great
detail in the process. Cherokee
Tragedy also provides ample
information on Ridge’s political dilemma regarding the removal
of the Cherokee. This
book is located at The University of Texas PCL Stacks in Austin,
Texas. This book can also
be referred to through Google Books.
Researcher:
Kendall Gray